Supercharge your investments with this new stock-picking method
Updated: May 28, 2025
If you rely on volatility to trade, then you will be interested in a recent study called "Procyclical Stocks Earn Higher Returns" by researchers Ai, Croce, Diercks, and Li (aka a group of smart folks) which claims certain stocks are more volatile during different economic cycles.

This research presents compelling evidence that some company stocks are "procyclical" meaning they will outperform their competition and the market in certain economic cycles because they move with business cycles, earning higher average returns on investment than non-cyclical stocks.
In other words, the study implies that certain stocks will provide higher returns during periods of economic prosperity and growth, while experiencing declining returns during economic downturns. So just like penny stocks, these stocks have a tendency fluctuate wildly; a bit like a rollercoaster!

Of course this unique characteristic of these procyclical stocks can be both a blessing and a curse for investing, depending on your timing and risk appetite.
In times of economic boom, procyclical stocks have the potential to deliver you handsome returns, outperforming so-called 'defensive' stocks that typically fare better in downturns. However, during economic recessions, procyclical stocks are more vulnerable to market volatility and can lead to significant losses in your portfolio if not managed prudently.
Key Findings
While the concept of cyclicality in stocks isn't new, this study provides a rigorous framework to measure how much a company's success goes up and down with the overall economy.
Here's what they did:
1. They looked at two things: a) How fast a company's profits were growing b) How fast
people in general were increasing their spending ("aggregate consumption growth")
2. They then checked how these two things moved together over time ("covariance" - it's a
fancy way of saying "do these two things tend to go up and down together?")
3. If a company's profit growth often went up when overall spending went up (and down
when spending went down), they said this company was more "cyclical".
4. If a company's profits didn't really match the pattern of overall spending, they said it was
less cyclical.
So, in sum, Ai & co were trying to figure out which companies do well when everyone and their uncle is spending more money, and which companies don't change as much no matter what's happening in the overall economy.
This new metric helped them sort companies into "more cyclical" and "less cyclical" groups, which was key to their study about stock returns.

So how can I find these ‘magic’ procyclical stocks?
Here are some ways to find procyclical stocks, along with a few examples, though it's important to note that this requires some research and understanding of economic indicators:
· Research the whole market: some sectors are naturally more procyclical than others.
· Look for Beta values: 'Riskier' stocks with 'higher beta' (>1) tend to be more procyclical.
· Look closely at a company's financial statements to determine if its revenues and profits
tend to move with economic cycles.
· Economic sensitivity reports: some financial websites and brokers provide reports on
companies' economic sensitivity.
· Correlation with economic indicators: look for stocks that have a high positive
correlation with indicators like GDP growth or consumer spending.
To help get you started, here are some examples of procyclical stocks:
Caterpillar (CAT): Construction equipment manufacturer, sensitive to economic growth.
American Express (AXP): Financial services company, tends to do well when consumer spending is high.
Boeing (BA): Aerospace company, often sees increased orders during economic expansions.
Home Depot (HD): Home improvement retailer, benefits from strong housing markets and consumer confidence.
Marriott International (MAR): Hotel chain, performs well when travel and leisure spending increase.
Remember, a stock's cyclicality can change over time, and past performance doesn't guarantee future results. It's always important to do thorough research and consider multiple factors before making investment decisions.
Conclusion
The discovery of the procyclical stock premium not only important in advancing our understanding of asset pricing of stocks and stock market behaviour., but for the savvy investor and trader, it offers a new lens through which to view and potentially exploit market inefficiencies.
Could it revolutionize your approach to investing? Maybe. Will it make you the next Warren Buffett? Probably not. But we at TMU feel it adds another useful tool to our arsenal in understanding the complex and captivating world of stock market dynamics.
And as with any investment strategy, careful consideration of the challenges and limitations is essential.
Check back tomorrow for more daily insights.
The content provided on this blog is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial, investment, or legal advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we make no guarantees about the completeness, reliability, or accuracy of any content.
You should not rely solely on the information presented here when making financial decisions. Always consult with a licensed financial advisor, accountant, or other qualified professional before making any investment or financial decisions.
The views expressed on this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. The blog may contain links to third-party websites. We are not responsible for the content or accuracy of any third-party sites linked to from this blog.
Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
By using this blog, you agree that the author is not responsible for any financial losses or damages that may arise from reliance on the information provided.





Comments